Medical study places without entrance exam restrictions — in Europe and worldwide

Personally guided by Marcel Kloos, founder of Medschool Experts, from your first consultation to the start of your career.
Book a free consultation
  • The right university for you — and a secure placement
  • A study place abroad with no entrance exam, internationally recognised
  • Support with enrolment, preparation and finding accommodation
  • Support with your university transfer
  • Guidance all the way to your first job as a doctor
Quick survey · anonymous
What was the main reason your studies came to a halt?
One question, ten seconds. Your answers feed directly into our advising — and into the next analysis here in the magazine.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Anonymous. We use your answers internally only, to improve our advising — never shared with third parties.
Magazine

AI agents in medicine: what Australia's scribe dispute means for future doctors

AI agents in medicine: what Australia's scribe dispute means for future doctors

05.11.2026

6 min read Lesezeit

Short answer

AI agents in medicine: Australia's TGA says 8 of 12 AI scribes reviewed are likely medical devices. What the Heidi dispute means for future doctors.

AI agents in medicine have reached Australian consulting rooms ahead of settled rules: on 16 October 2026 the Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA) said eight of the 12 AI scribes it reviewed have functions likely to meet the definition of a medical device. Thirteen days later, a licence dispute broke out over software that works inside patient records under a doctor's login.

Neither event threatens tomorrow's doctors. Both show where their value lies.

Last reviewed: November 2026.

What is the dispute between Heidi and Best Practice about?

The 2026 Australian dispute concerns Heidi II, AI agents launched in late September that operate practice software through the doctor's own login. Best Practice, which supplies Bp Premier, says this use breaches its licence. Heidi says it sought a proper integration for three years without reasonable access. Both statements are the parties' own positions.

On 29 October, Best Practice chief executive Craig Hodges told users that the coming Oxford SP2 update will explicitly ban bots, scraping and robotic process automation. He cited patient safety, privacy law and the TGA finding. Heidi's chief executive, Dr Thomas Kelly, accepts that Best Practice may rely on its terms but rejects safety and privacy as its real motive. Heidi has terms too. They ban "any automated means (including bots, scrapers, or scripts)" on its platform, and Heidi has said it will update them.

Are AI scribes medical devices in Australia?

AI scribes in Australia are not medical devices when they only record, transcribe or translate what the doctor said. In 2026 the Therapeutic Goods Administration said software likely becomes a device once it generates clinical conclusions, diagnoses, treatments or investigations that the practitioner did not state.

The TGA identified about 100 suppliers and took 12 products to closer review. Eight were likely devices, two needed more information and two appeared unlikely to qualify. The agency named no products and tested neither safety nor performance, so a flag does not mean a product is unsafe or a supplier broke the law.

That sample is roughly one supplier in eight, chosen by the agency, so two-thirds is no market rate. Look at the other number. None of the 12 suppliers had identified its product as a device.

Who is responsible when an AI agent works under a doctor's login?

In Australia in 2026, the treating doctor stays professionally responsible for care and records, even when an AI agent did the work. Ahpra, the national practitioner regulator, says the practitioner must check records created with generative AI, while licence obligations for practice software rest with the practice rather than the AI supplier.

A login is a name. Whatever an agent enters under it reads, on the face of the record, as that doctor's own work. Kelly himself told a Melbourne summit that agents should use their own credentials and that technology companies should accept liability for their products. Those are proposals, not law.

How do Australia, the UK, the USA and the EU regulate AI scribes?

Australia, the UK, the USA and the EU all judge AI scribes by function in 2026, yet draw the line differently. Plain documentation generally sits outside device rules in the UK and the USA, Australia focuses on added clinical content, and the EU asks whether software informs clinical decisions.

JurisdictionMain rules in 2026Usually outside device rulesLikely a device
AustraliaTherapeutic Goods Act 1989Recording, transcribing or translating without adding clinical contentSuggesting diagnoses, treatments or investigations; generating clinical conclusions
United KingdomMHRA guidance, 29 July 2026Summaries, letters and codes for a clinician to checkSupporting diagnosis or treatment; automated action without clinician review, such as placing orders
USA21st Century Cures Act; FDA guidance, January 2026Administrative support; electronic patient recordsRecommendations whose basis the clinician cannot independently review
European UnionMedical Device Regulation; AI Act high-risk duties for devices from 2 August 2028Software with no medical purposeSoftware informing diagnostic or therapeutic decisions

The UK changed course: NHS England's 2025 guidance leaned towards treating summarising scribes as devices, and the MHRA's July 2026 guidance said summarising alone does not make them so.

A first-year on a six-year programme starting this autumn graduates in 2032, and the EU's August 2028 date arrives before year three. Expect this table to change. A habit of checking will travel better than any rulebook.

{{cta}}

Will doctors stay in the loop as AI agents spread?

Doctors stay in the loop in 2026 because regulators and companies alike leave clinical decisions with a clinician. The UK treats automated action without review as device territory, and Heidi's co-founder told a Melbourne summit that anything informing diagnosis, investigation or management must be reviewed and approved by a clinician.

That summit fell on 29 October, the day of the Best Practice letter, and the sector split on pace. Heidi described agents drafting discharge instructions. Aspen Medical's chief medical officer, Dr Katrina Sanders, said her company is "not convinced about the risk-reward benefit at this point in time". Amplar Health's AI flags risks for clinicians: "It's recommendations only."

The clinician stays. In the USA, decision support escapes device status only if the professional can independently review its basis.

Which skills will medical students need alongside AI agents?

Medical students in 2026 should build what software cannot sign for: clinical reasoning, careful history-taking, physical examination and checking machine output against the patient. As AI agents absorb documentation, a doctor's value moves towards judgement, consent conversations and spotting the error in a well-written note.

Polished drafts mislead. The FDA warns that automation bias grows when action is urgent, so learn to write your own notes before relying on a machine's. A scribe captures what was said, and the unsaid part stays with you.

For the wider career picture, read why doctors are still needed in the AI era and how science graduates are moving into medicine, or compare medical programmes worldwide.

The author's view

I started dental school in Sofia in 2015, aged 24, on an English-language programme, and finished with the class of 2021. My name on a record still means I answer for it. I take no side in a licence dispute. I do think a login should belong to one person, and any agent in a patient record should leave its own trace.

Applicants should stop asking whether AI will take the job. Ask whether you could defend a note you did not write, in front of the patient it describes. I would like every medical school to test that.

Summary

  • The TGA said in October 2026 that eight of 12 reviewed AI scribes likely have device functions, without naming them.
  • Best Practice says Heidi II breaches its licence; Heidi says it was denied reasonable access.
  • Ahpra keeps responsibility with the practitioner.
  • Clinician review shapes the device line in all four jurisdictions.

Conclusion

Agents will take over more screen work. Patients will still need someone who examines, decides and answers for the result.

If that could be you, talk to Marcel or another experienced consultant on our team about where to study medicine.

Frequently asked questions

Will AI agents replace doctors in Australia?

Nothing in Australia's 2026 rules points that way. Ahpra keeps practitioners responsible for care and for checking AI-generated records, and even firms deploying agents say clinical decisions need clinician approval. Agents are taking on documentation, which leaves doctors more of the work that depends on judgement.

Is Heidi II banned in Australia?

The conflict is contractual. Best Practice says using Heidi II with Bp Premier breaches its licence and that its Oxford SP2 update will explicitly ban bots, scraping and robotic process automation. Other vendors have their own terms, so each practice has to read its licence.

Do patients have to consent to AI scribes in Australia?

Ahpra advises Australian practitioners to obtain informed consent before using generative AI scribes that require personal data, and ideally to note the patient's response in the health record. Practitioners should also tell patients about their use of AI and consider any concerns raised.

Should AI agents change where I study medicine?

AI agents should not put anyone off medicine, and studying abroad remains a real, strong route. Device rules differ between countries, but careful examination, clinical reasoning and checking every record travel well. Doctors trained abroad know more than one health system, a real strength.

Your question · answer by email
Still have a question?
Write it here. I'll respond by email and, if it helps others, include it anonymously in the Q&A for this article.
Thanks — your question has arrived. You will get an answer by email, usually within two working days.
That didn't work, unfortunately. Please try again or contact us using the contact form.
We use your email address solely to reply to your question. No sharing with third parties, no newsletter.

What students say about Medschool Experts

Over 500 placements at 25+ partner universities across 10+ countries. See how our students experienced their path into medical school abroad in our student stories.

Read student stories

About the author

Marcel Kloos

Founder and owner of Medschool Experts, federally recognised dentist

Marcel Kloos is the founder and owner of Medschool Experts, a placement agency for medicine, dentistry, veterinary medicine and pharmacy degrees abroad. Since 2021 the team has secured more than 500 study places at 25+ partner universities in Europe and worldwide.

Study medicine abroad: Marcel's own path

Born in Stuttgart, Marcel started his degree late: at 24 he enrolled at the Medical University of Sofia, Faculty of Dental Medicine, and graduated in 2021 from the English-language programme. He went through the same steps his clients face today — nostrification of school certificates, entrance interviews, finding a flat in Sofia and later the recognition of a foreign degree. He is a federally recognised dentist.

What Marcel does at Medschool Experts

Today Marcel lives in Bern and runs Medschool Experts full-time. He visits every partner university in person, negotiates placement agreements directly with faculties and deans, and leads the free consultations in which applicants learn at which university they can start next semester. His YouTube channel on studying medicine abroad has helped thousands of applicants compare universities, costs and recognition.

Topics Marcel writes about

  • Study medicine abroad independent of your high school diploma grades: universities, costs and admission
  • Study dentistry, veterinary medicine or pharmacy in Europe in English
  • Tuition fees and living costs at medical schools in Europe and worldwide
  • Recognition of foreign medical degrees in the EU, Switzerland, the UK and the US
  • Transferring between medical schools and returning home into a higher semester

All articles by Marcel Kloos are based on first-hand visits to the universities and conversations with current students. Book a free consultation to discuss your own path.

More articles worth reading

Medical School Tuition Statistics 2026: Median Fees in 38 Countries

Countries

9 min read Lesezeit

Medical School Tuition Statistics 2026: Median Fees in 38 Countries

Marcel Kloos

Marcel Kloos

22.11.2026

Read article
Oldest Universities Where You Can Study Medicine: Founding Dates from 1088

Universities

8 min read Lesezeit

Oldest Universities Where You Can Study Medicine: Founding Dates from 1088

Marcel Kloos

Marcel Kloos

22.11.2026

Read article
English-Taught Medical Schools 2026: 455 Programmes in 49 Countries

Medical Studies Abroad

7 min read Lesezeit

English-Taught Medical Schools 2026: 455 Programmes in 49 Countries

Marcel Kloos

Marcel Kloos

22.11.2026

Read article
View all articles
Portrait photo of Ahmad, Medschool Experts client

Ahmad

Portrait photo of Sabrina, Medschool Experts client

Sabrina

Portrait photo of Rami, Medschool Experts client

Rami

Portrait photo of Noah, Medschool Experts client

Noah

500+ students placed.
Now it's your turn!

No daydreaming, no empty promises. Just a clear plan — for the start of your medical degree.

Book a free consultation
  • 40 minutes, no obligation